Post -Test Self Assessment: Giving Specific Feedback


A lot of educators have expressed frustration over the A-F Report card system that basically sums up the effectiveness of the entire school to one letter grade.  One of the big complaint(there are many) revolves around the fact that it is impossible for one letter to really tell us everything that goes into the success (or lack of success) of a schools.

I bring this up, not to get into the local politics of education, but to illustrate a point.  As teachers, how can we make sure we are giving students the feedback they need in order to improve?  Sometimes it is easy to fall into the habit of simply reporting grades to students, rather than providing feedback that leads to improvement.

With over one hundred and fifty students, teachers understandable have a hard time of providing useful feedback for students after each assessment, especially following multiple choice tests.  We give the test, pass back the scores, and sometimes we go over the questions that a lot of students missed.  Then we move on.

I wanted to share a strategy that asks us to do just a little bit more in order to give students a clear picture of their own progress.  Clicking the link at the top will take you to a word document of the following chart:



Objective or Learning Target
DOK Level  (1-4) Right Wrong Oops! ??? Justification: (Use evidence from text where appropriate).

The Process

Step 1:After creating assessment, teacher lists the objective or learning target that the question addresses and the Depth of Knowledge Level (optional).


Step 2:  Teacher passes out test results and students mark the ones they missed,


Step 3: Students look at the questions and decide if they missed it because they really didn’t know it, or if it was just a simple mistake.

Step 4: Students correct the questions they missed and write justifications based on the text (this should be done pretty soon after the test was taken, so it is still fresh in their minds).



A number of activities could be used to follow this self-evaluation:

– Students analyze patterns based on the test and rank objectives/learning targets in order of difficulty for them.

– Students brainstorm ideas about how they can go back and “prove” they have relearned the content (Student-directed assessment).

– Students can use this process to track and even chart their own progress (especially if the DoK’s are listed).

– Students can create their own learning goals based on results of the assessment

– Students can reflect on what activities (note-taking, small group activities…) contributed to their learning of the content.

Sports Metaphor:

Here I go with another sports metaphor.  Any athlete learning a skill needs almost immediate feedback on how he is executing that skill.  Take a youth soccer player who keeps kicking with his toe, even though his coach is constantly preaching the youth soccer coach mantra, “Say No to the Toe!”  To be more effective that player may need specific feedback from that coach immediately after he kicks the ball poorly.  The feedback would also have to be specific and may involve having the player perform it correctly before he is let off the hook.  Imagine if coaches just said you aren’t doing it right get back in line and try again, or even worse expecting them to do it right in a game with never having been coached to do it correctly in practice.

In the classroom, let’s make sure we are as explicit as possible with students about their strengths and weaknesses in relationship to the standards.  It seems logical that a student who realizes what he does and doesn’t know has a lot better chance to succeed than a student who doesn’t.





Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s